-
Strategies for a discontinuous future.












Wednesday, June 02, 2004
 


Politics of the Day

Hey, look, it's someone who has no idea what they're talking about:

"...Wait a minute! It's illegal in California to give "preferential treatment to friends of top management"? ... Obvious points: a) It's rational for efficient managers to promote their friends, whom they probably trust more (and who may owe them a greater loyalty) than other employees; b) Business--indeed, virtually all organized human activity--might not grind to a halt if this rule were imposed, but it would grind to a half-halt."

1) In no sense is this rational. In fact, cronyism and nepotism are what we might call completely irrational. It should be patently obvious why - even if we say trust is worth something, it should always be worth less than ability, because we have mechanisms to ensure trust, but NOT to ensure ability. The only way this argument works is if you first admit that our trust-making mechanisms (contracts, the SEC, Friendster) don't work - which defeats the whole point of the argument in the first place.

2) Human activity wouldn't 'grind to a half-halt' - in fact, it would become much more efficient. All the evidence in the known universe suggests that the vast majority of us would be immensely better off without nepotism and cronyism. You may want to consider moving to Zimbabwe - I hear Mugabe's a fan of theories like this.

Dear Mickey, I suggest you read a nice book called Saving Capitalism From the Capitalists, which is written, paradoxically, by two of world's top finance profs.

Luv,

Umair

-- umair // 5:23 PM //


Comments:
Post a Comment
search



new


input

due diligence
ventureblog
a vc
techblurbs
tj's weblog
venture chronicles
terranova
the big picture
gigaom
venchar
bill burnham
babak nivi
n-c thoughts
paidcontent
techdirt
slashdot
london gsb
mefi
boingboing
blort
hardwax
betalounge

ing
morgan
chicago fed
dallas fed
ny fed
imf
world bank
nouriel roubini

portfolio
contact

mail.
uhaque (dot) mba2003 (at) london (dot) edu

skype.
umair.haque

atom feed

technorati profile

blog archives