Umair Haque / Bubblegeneration
umair haque  


Design principles for 21st century companies, markets, and economies. Foreword by Gary Hamel. Coming January 4th. Pre-order at Amazon.

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Unvarnished and the Economics of Antisocial Media

Let's talk about an interesting new startup for a sec: Unvarnished. It's an open feedback system, with a few notable catches. You can't delete bad feedback, and feedback is loosely anonymous (in the sense that it's untraceable to anyone's real-world identity).

The really big problem with Unvarnished is simple - so simple, the founders have completely and totally overlooked it. For the average person, the supply of bad feedback vastly exceeds the supply of good feedback. If you had perfect professional feedback, you'd be a CEO (or better yet, retired before the age of 25). So Unvarnished is inherently biased against the average Joe, who inherently has more negative than positive feedback - that is, after all, what being a mid-level professional means.

But wait, there's more. So much more.

Consider a hypothetical Unvarnished post about...Steve Jobs.

"Obsessive, megalomaniacal, abusive, control freak. Responsible for screwing up a major product that nearly led to the collapse of a major Silicon Valley company".

Sounds pretty bad, gives one pause. Except, of course, it gives us exactly the wrong information about the value of Steve to Apple. Jobs is the world's most valuable CEO, by a long way - but Unvarnished wouldn't give you much hint of that. 

Why would that post surface? What about Unvarnished's so-called democratic self-regulation? There isn't any, really. The "community" has no better information about the veracity of a reviewer than my goldfish does, and asking them to vote a reviewer up or down is about as meaningful as asking my goldfish to choose the bicycle he likes the best.

Asymmetrical information - and a massive oversupply of bads - inevitably breed massive adverse selection. Unvarnished is a breeding ground for adverse selection in feedback itself. The least accurate, most overly negative feedback will rise to the top, making hiring decisions even less efficient than they are today. 

Here's another, simpler, way to look at it. Unvarnished is a social Ponzi scheme - borrowing reputation from another, to amp up one's own (until one's own gets trashed). Those economics are so 20th century, it hurts.

Unvarnished is the endgame of the "social web". I'm going to mark it as the day the "social web" became antisocial. Increasingly, today's "social web" doesn't empower people. It empowers hate, exclusion, and polarization, to put it bluntly. That's as lame and brain-dead as what went on on Wall St a few years back: hurting others to extract value from them. Except, of course, Wall St actually made billions. Social media's as bankrupt financially as it is ethically and economically: a trifecta of lameness.

Count me out of this charade of faux sociality. You - investor, entrepreneur, banker, student, whomever - might want to rethink it too. It's time to build a better economy. And that sure ain't gonna happen by building miniature social Ponziconomies. 

-- umair // 6:14 AM // 15 comments

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Chicken or Egg? DNA.

There's an interesting discussion taking place about the causes of the crisis - and crises in general. Was it a global savings glut that caused an asset bubble - or did an asset bubble invoke the need for more financing, inducing larger savings? 

It may sound arcane, but it has tremendous implication for policy and strategy. If asset bubbles lead to savings gluts (rather than vice versa), then monitoring and puncturing them at the macroprudential level takes precedence over interest rate manipulation and inflation targeting. 

For companies, there's an even more interesting implication. Evil, lame 20th century corporations depend critically on global consumption rates staying sky-high in at least some parts of the globe - financed by excess savings in others. So this research suggests that strategy 2.0 begins by not fuelling asset bubbles, but puncturing them gently - so imbalances never spiral out of control.

Yet, I think the question of root causes hasn't been fully addressed yet.

Which came first - the chicken, or the egg? The DNA. That's my take on the above debate. The real root cause of crises and collapses are in the institutional DNA. When institutions are hollowed and emptied, a crash, a collapse - or a series of them - is the inevitable result. Amrica's asset bubbles and China's savings gluts are manifestations of a deeper bankruptcy - institutional bankruptcy, that renders both economies unable to allocate capital productively in the first place.

-- umair // 10:14 PM // 4 comments


Daily Tweets

Here's a collection of my tweets from yesterday (thanks, Viewsflow).

MTV Developing 'Co-Viewing' Apps for the iPad - Advertising Age - Digital - 59% of people multi-task when watching TV, tablet & mobile devices easier to play with while watching than computers. ...

Facebook Wants You to “Like” Brands

Mashable - the textbook example of the social media bubble. ...

Quora Raises $11 Million for Web Q&A Service | Digital Media Wire - it's nice, but is quora gonna help build a better financial/media/edu/health industry? <- ventureconomy in decay ...

Don’t Be Shocked by Jobs Boom Next Week - Real Time Economics - WSJ - wall st says: there's about to be a "jobs boom". i'm calling bs. weclome to your mcjob. ...

Alternate Economic Measure Suggests Strong End to 2009 - Real Time Economics - WSJ - totally bogus. these will be revised downwards without a doubt. ...

Critic Group Urges Fed to Act to Control Inflation - Real Time Economics - WSJ - after the liquidity trap? the liquidity exit trap. (via @umairh) ...

Hulu's a Towering Success -- Just Not Financially - Advertising Age - Digital - econ 101 suggested long ago: the same old lame ads would never make hulu (etc) seriously profitable. so here you go. ...

Facebook Wants You to “Like” Brands - Facebook Wants You to “Like” Brands ...

Smart! Microsoft Chose 'Bing' Over 'Bang' For Its Search Engine Name

Business Insider - Smart! Microsoft Chose 'Bing' Over 'Bang' For Its Search Engine Name $MSFT by @jwyarow ...

Thinning Out - On the Runway Blog - - interesting discussion on magazines. polyvore + ipad = fashion 2.0. ...

Hulu - The Future Of Food - Watch the full feature film now. - Future of food, amazing #food #agriculture #health ...

-- umair // 3:43 PM // 0 comments


About Me

Forgive me, but I'm (mostly) an economist. My real blog is here, at Harvard Business Review. I'm the Director of the Havas Media Lab. I give lots of talks, speeches, and workshops. This year, they're focused on reconceiving capitalism.

I started Bubblegen as a blog when I was doing my MBA. It turned into a strategy and innovation advisory boutique that worked with top-tier investors, entrepreneurs, and blue-chip corporates to build a better kind of business.

I studied neuroscience at McGill, did an MBA and research with Gary Hamel at London Business School, and more postgraduate work in economics, strategy, and innovation at Oxford. Before I grew up, I was a writer, banker, derivatives trader, and strategist. I live around here, in London.

If you'd like to get in touch, you're welcome to drop me a line anytime.

-- umair // 5:44 AM // 0 comments



I write a lot - and a lot of what I write can feel opaque, until you're familiar with some of my key concepts. So here's a crash course in Umair 101.

(Soon :)

-- umair // 5:41 AM // 0 comments



Every so often, I write a manifesto. Here's the collection so far. They're a really good place to begin exploring the key themes we discuss regularly.

The Awesomeness Manifesto
The Generation M Manifesto
The Smart Growth Manifesto
The Builders' Manifesto 
The Finance 2.0 Manifesto
The Nichepaper Manifesto
A Manifesto for the Next Industrial Revolution
The Great to Good Manifesto

-- umair // 5:29 AM // 2 comments


Recent Tweets


    due diligence
    a vc
    tj's weblog
    venture chronicles
    the big picture
    bill burnham
    babak nivi
    n-c thoughts
    london gsb

    chicago fed
    dallas fed
    ny fed
    world bank
    nouriel roubini


    uhaque (dot) mba2003 (at) london (dot) edu


    atom feed

    technorati profile

    blog archives